The Research Institute for Compassionate Economics (RICE) survey a random sample of 1550 households in 11 districts of Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, Uttar Pradesh, and Rajasthan. Collectively, these households were two-fifths of the country's rural population.
According to the study, the following observations were made on the implementation of PMUY:
Use of chulhas: The study revealed that most rural households who have taken LPG connections still use chulhas with dung cakes or firewood.
- Overall, only 27 percent of the households were exclusively using the gas stoves.
- Another 37 percent of the households were using both the chulhas and the gas stove.
- On the other hand, 36 percent of the households used chulhas exclusively.
Use of Solid fuel: Around 85 percent of the PMUY beneficiaries in rural India (in the four states surveyed) were using the solid fuels even after the implementation of the scheme because of financial reasons and reasons of gender inequalities.
Increase in LPG ownership: In all the four states, there was a substantial increase in LPG ownership.
- Due to the implementation of PMUY, 76 percent of household owned the LPG connection.
- Among those who have received an LPG connection, 53 percent of these households used chulha, and 32 percent of households used both media of cooking.
- Refilling the cylinder: Since the beneficiaries of PMUY are poor, for them the refilling of cylinder forms a greater fraction of their monthly consumption. Therefore, they are less likely to get refill immediately when a cylinder is empty.
Cost of refill: Since almost
70 percent of rural households do not have to spend upon the solid fuels, the relative cost of refilling an LPG cylinder is far higher. The cost is higher even if the same is subsidized.
Gender inequalities: In rural India, women are not economic decision-makers in the household, which was a major hindrance in the shift to LPG usage.
- Seventy percent of respondents (who were mainly females) thought that the gas stove was better for the health of the cook.
- More than 86 percent of the respondents believed that cooking food on chulha was good for the health of the family.
Both these facts symbolized the ignorance of the households towards the ambient air pollution. This pollution is harmful to those who are cooking and not cooking the food.
Besides many issues emerging in the policy implementation, the WHO has acknowledged
PMUY as a decisive intervention of the Indian Government to address the issue of indoor air pollution. Therefore, there is hope to achieve much more soon.